Laurel Hall Earns Place on the National Register of Historic Places

One of Indianapolis’ most treasured historic landmarks has received national recognition.

Laurel Hall, the historic headquarters of Phi Kappa Psi and one of the city’s most remarkable examples of English Tudor Revival architecture, was officially listed on the National Register of Historic Places on May 28, 2026.

The designation marks the culmination of more than two years of research, documentation, and preservation efforts led by the Phi Psi Foundation in partnership with historic preservation consultant Kurt West Garner of KW Garner Consulting. The process began in early 2024 when Foundation leaders sought to determine whether the property met the criteria for National Register recognition. Following extensive historical research and architectural analysis, the nomination was submitted to the Indiana Division of Historic Preservation & Archaeology and ultimately recommended to the National Park Service on April 15, 2026. The National Park Service subsequently approved the listing.

Constructed in 1916 as the country estate of Indianapolis banking heir Stoughton Fletcher, Laurel Hall remains one of the finest and most intact examples of English Tudor Revival architecture in Indiana. Perched atop a landscaped hill on the city’s northeast side, the estate is distinguished by its brick and stone exterior, green tile roof, intricate carved stonework, stained and leaded art glass windows, and extraordinary interior wood craftsmanship. More than a century later, the property continues to reflect the vision of its original architect, with its historic character and sweeping vistas largely preserved.

Beyond its architectural significance, Laurel Hall played an important role in Indianapolis educational history. For nearly 45 years, the estate served as the home of Ladywood School, later known as Ladywood-St. Agnes School, a respected Catholic boarding and day school that attracted students from across Indiana and beyond. Known for its academic rigor and distinctive educational experience, Ladywood became a landmark institution for generations of young women.

Today, Laurel Hall serves as the national headquarters of Phi Kappa Psi, while also welcoming the broader community as a venue for weddings, celebrations, meetings, and special events. Since acquiring the property in 2005, the Phi Kappa Psi Foundation has invested significantly in preserving and stewarding the historic estate for future generations.

“This designation recognizes not only the architectural beauty of Laurel Hall, but also the generations of individuals whose lives have been shaped by this remarkable place,” said Ben Nicol, Chief Executive Officer of the Phi Psi Foundation. “We are honored to serve as its steward and remain committed to preserving its history while ensuring it continues to be a vibrant and meaningful part of the Indianapolis community.”

Established under the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, the National Register of Historic Places is the nation’s official list of sites, buildings, structures, and districts worthy of preservation for their historical, architectural, archaeological, or cultural significance. Listing on the National Register helps recognize and protect important historic resources while opening opportunities for preservation incentives, including rehabilitation grants and tax credits for qualifying projects.

With its addition to the National Register, Laurel Hall joins an elite group of historic places that tell the story of America’s architectural, educational, and cultural heritage, ensuring that its legacy will endure for generations to come.